🌍 Foreign Seller Identification Failure Costs Title Company $202K
A title agency faced major FIRPTA liability after relying on a driver’s license and seller affidavit to verify U.S. citizenship. Learn why foreign seller verification protocols matter.
Foreign Seller Identification Failure Costs Title Company $202K! Don’t let this happen to your agency!
Background
A title agency in an emerging real estate market processed the sale of a $925,000 residential property. The seller presented a U.S. driver’s license and completed a standard seller affidavit indicating U.S. citizenship.
The Situation
Eighteen months after closing, an IRS compliance review discovered the seller was actually a non-resident alien who maintained a U.S. driver’s license from previous temporary residence. The title agent had relied solely on the driver’s license and affidavit without additional verification.
Enforcement Details
Required withholding: $138,750 (15% of $925,000)
Documentation issues: Insufficient verification of seller’s actual tax status
Additional penalties: $41,625 (30% penalty for failure to reasonably verify status)
Interest assessment: $22,200 (accumulated over 24 months)
Total liability: $202,575
Impact on Underwriter
Title agency contested the assessment but lost on appeal
Agency unable to pay full amount due to insufficient reserves
E&O carrier denied claim citing “inadequate verification procedures”
Underwriter ultimately responsible for $145,000 under agency agreement
Underwriter implemented mandatory Foreign Seller Verification Protocol for all agents
How Proper FIRPTA Compliance Would Have Prevented This
A proper FIRPTA identification protocol would have:
Required additional documentation beyond driver’s license
Implemented specific foreign seller identification questions
Established clear “suspicious circumstance” guidelines requiring enhanced verification
Provided proper documentation procedures protecting against misrepresentation




Discussion about this post