🐐FinCEN What Took You So Long? They Finally Answer THE Question We've All Been Asking
After appealing the Flowers decision, FinCEN quietly dropped the clarification title agents have been desperately waiting for — and it changes the operational risk dramatically.
Thank you to our friends, contributors & sponsors:🔒 Closinglock, 🌍 Foreign Tax CPA, 🧱 Brickhouse Consulting, 🖊️Dotted Line Signings & Our Paying Readers
FinCEN Offers Guidance on Real Estate Reporting Requirements if the Rule Returns
Treasury is appealing the nationwide vacatur — but FinCEN just confirmed title agents won’t have to go back and resurrect months of dead files if the rule returns.
Yesterday, we talked about the bigger legal fight unfolding around the Residential Real Estate Reporting Rule:
Treasury appealed the Texas decision vacating the rule nationwide.
Fidelity appealing in Florida.
FinCEN clearly isn’t backing down.
The possibility of the rule returning is now very real again.
In case you missed it, you can read 🐐FinCEN Isn’t Backing Down: Treasury Appeals the Texas Decision Vacating the Real Estate Reporting Rule here.
But buried underneath all the legal drama was the operational nightmare nobody wanted to think about:
“What happens to the files that closed during the vacatur?”
Well.
FinCEN finally answered that question.
According to FinCEN’s newly updated FAQs, while the Texas court order remains in effect:
reporting persons are not required to file Real Estate Reports
and are not liable for failing to file them.
But more importantly:
If the government eventually wins the appeal and the rule comes back?
FinCEN says reporting persons will not have to retroactively file reports for transactions that closed during the vacatur period.
What a relief! It’s official, you will not need to reopen the compliance crypt and start digging through six months of old LLC cash deals like a forensic archaeologist with PTSD.
The Treasury appealing the decision tells us the government still intends to fight for this rule in some form.
But this FAQ update also tells us something equally important:
FinCEN understands the operational burden retroactive reporting would create and they do want to work with our industry and be as practical as possible while still achieving their goals.
🐐 About Wicked Title | 🔔 Subscribe | 📢 Be a Sponsor
Puerto Rico Pauses
The Puerto Rico plaintiffs and the government jointly asked the court to stay the case because the Flowers vacatur already gave the plaintiffs what they wanted: the rule is currently unenforceable nationwide while the appeal plays out. The bigger implication is that everyone — including DOJ — is now treating the Fifth Circuit appeal in Flowers as the main battlefield that will likely determine the future of the RRE Rule nationwide, and potentially set the stage for Supreme Court involvement if the circuit split deepens.
What Title Agencies Should Do Now: Preparation Without Burden
This does not mean the rule is dead.
And it definitely does not mean you should dismantle every process you built around entity transaction screening, because the appeal itself still matters.
For now, the smartest operational posture is probably:
pause active filing obligations
preserve the institutional knowledge you built
keep your intake and screening processes in place
Continue training any new staff on compliance requirements
and keep watching the appeals closely
What the FAQs doesn’t promise is just as important as what it does promise.
FinCEN has not promised a 90 day delay, or any sort of guidance around transactions IN PROCESS. So you still need to keep collecting that information because the possibility that the rule returns, in some form, and applies to active transactions, is still entirely possible.
The rule’s fate remains in the courts’ hands, but FinCEN’s May 18 guidance provides title professionals the clarity needed to make informed decisions about compliance infrastructure and operational readiness during this period of legal uncertainty.
🐐The FinCEN Drama Isn’t Over — Wicked Title Will Keep an Eye on The Chaos For You
The legal situation around FinCEN is evolving fast right now, and I know a lot of title agents are feeling somewhere between “cautiously optimistic” and “one compliance email away from a stress-induced eye twitch.”
So don’t worry — I’m watching this closely for you.
As new court filings, appeals, guidance, operational clarifications, and industry reactions emerge, I’ll keep breaking down what’s happening, what it actually means, and most importantly:
what title agents should realistically do next.
No panic.
No legalese word salad.
No doomposting.
Just practical updates for real people trying to keep files moving while the regulatory universe catches fire around them.
🐐 Stay wicked, title sharks 🦈
Cheryl
Contact Me (or hit reply)
🐐 About Wicked Title | 🔍 Search the Knowledge Base | 📢 Be a Sponsor
The Wicked Title Forum is a collaborative resource. If you spot something outdated or inaccurate, leave a comment—we’ll get it fixed.
**DISCLAIMER**
Content is for informational purposes, operational awareness and workflow strategy. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, it is not meant to be a compliance directive or replace the specific legal/financial advice of your retained experts. As always evaluate new information & tools with your underwriter/attorney, accountant/financial advisor, IT/security team, and internal policies, as needed, before implementation.
This site is partially supported by sponsor ads and sponsored content.